Process Board Information and Guidelines
Think
of
the process board as a conversation between you and the portfolio
reviewers
that allows them to understand how you think, how you make decisions,
and how
well you responded to the DSN S 102 assignment objectives. Remember that
the
reviewers won't have witnessed each stage of the project and won't be
able to
tell from the final piece just how much effort and good thinking went
into it.
In this sense, the process boards are similar to the presentations
you've made
in class at final critiques, when you've succinctly explained to the
jurors
what you intended, what you tried, and how you arrived at the final
decisions.
The
process board(s) should accomplish several things:
- Clarify your understanding of the project by
describing what you were asked to learn, and how you approached that
learning objective.
- Explain (with visual information) the
research you did and the visual sources of inspiration you considered.
Be
clear about which were required sources vs. which are unique to you
(i.e.,
everyone looked at assigned precedent examples, but what additional
sources did YOU look at?)
- Document the various stages of project
development, with clear explanations of how YOUR experiments and
solutions
are unique.
- Include self-critique. Why did some ideas NOT
work? Can you recognize situations where you were taking the wrong
direction? The reviewers want to know that you can learn from your
failures as well as your successes.
- Show that you tried more than one idea, and
explain why you selected the one that was developed for the final
solution.
- Remember that the reviewers will see your
portfolio as a series of stacked pages. They won't know, for example,
how
you intended your sequential section pages to be presented. Explain
things
like this on the process board.
- If there was a written component in a project
(like the tool essay in the pattern project, for example), briefly
summarize or excerpt your writing and include that on the process board.
Guidelines
in setting up the process boards:
- Prioritize
clarity and highlight the ideas at work in your projects.
- A
collage or cut-and-paste method of presenting the elements is fine;
there is no
expectation that you copy or scan everything onto a single surface. Just
make
sure the elements are well-adhered to the page and are in no danger of
falling
off as the pages move around.
- Your
self-assessment notes and explanations of sketches should be typed so
they're
easy to read. DO NOT go smaller than 9-point type. Use a standard,
readable
font (NOT a script, decorative, or ultra-bold font). If there are brief
handwritten notes directly on the sketches, they can be included, but
lengthy
handwritten notes should be typed to ensure that the reviewers can read
them.
- Give the
board titles and subtitles so that we know which part of the work is
"early
ideas" and which part constitutes "refinement."
- The
board should be clean, well-organized, and complete. It should NOT
incorporate
extraneous elements that merely decorate the page and/or distract from
the
content of the work.
- You can
use your original sketches—cut from sketchbooks—or good quality copies
of
them. Keep in mind that originals may be too big for the space you have.
For
team projects, use copies of the originals. Consider making color copies
of
sketches that have finely detailed pencil work.
- In
addition to sketches, the "refinement" stage might include photos of
rough
models.
-
If you
haven't yet documented your process work, you're asked to develop this
documentation now, looking back on the assignment and how you solved the
problem.